Pizza · The Buford slice
Pizza in Buford
The Buford pizza answer starts on Main Street: Italian Pizza Pie, the slice room in the old downtown storefronts at 39 East Main, with Johnny's New York Style Pizza carrying the Hamilton Mill corridor and Pizza Di Folco holding the lake side. Those three are the rooms worth driving for, and all are open and verified by name and address.
Buford has more pizza options than any other city on this corridor, so this page keeps the list to the verified rooms and names the national delivery chains only in the closing note. Hours and menus shift, so check the room before you order.
The pizza rooms
The pizzerias Buford drives to
Italian Pizza Pie
The downtown slice room on East Main, a proper old-storefront pizzeria with pies, calzones, and a lunch counter. The historic Main Street answer.
Johnny's New York Style Pizza
The New York-style room on the Hamilton Mill corridor, big slices and whole pies for the Mill side of the city.
Pizza Di Folco
The lake-side house on Little Mill Road, a real local pizzeria serving the Lanier Islands end of Buford.
The rest of the list
Two more rooms worth naming
Pizza by Vinny's
A New York-style kitchen on the Lanier Islands Parkway, the south end's dependable slice on the way to the lake.
Italy's Pizza & Pasta Company
A pizza-and-pasta room on the Hamilton Mill Road strip, one of the older names in the area.
The national delivery names sit on the Buford Highway and Buford Drive corridors too, Papa Johns, Pizza Hut, Little Caesars, and Domino's, for the nights nobody cooks. The full dining picture, from Main Street to the mill corridor, is on the Buford restaurants page.
An editorial guide, not a listings site. Updated September 22, 2026. Real-estate guidance on this page is provided by Rob Dietrich, REALTOR® with eXp Realty, LLC.